Pension Lump Sum vs Annuity: Which Is Worth More?

Pension lump sum vs annuity: the two are worth the same when the monthly pension equals what the lump sum would buy as a life annuity. At the 4.95% 10-year Treasury yield of November 3, 2026 (Treasury), priced on the SSA period life table with no insurer charges, $100,000 buys about $761 a month for life at 65 for a man and $690 for a woman. If your plan offers more than that per $100,000 of lump sum, the annuity is worth more to someone of average health; if it offers less, the lump sum is. The longer you expect to live, the better the annuity.

What a $100,000 lump sum is worth as a monthly pension

Fair monthly life income from $100,000, first payment a month after it starts, level (no cost-of-living increase), priced on the SSA 2022 period life table at the 4.95% 10-year Treasury par yield of November 3, 2026 (Treasury), nothing kept for costs. Joint = a man and a woman of the same age, 100% to the survivor.
Age when it startsManWomanJoint and 100% survivor
55$617$571$518
60$678$622$555
62$708$646$573
65$761$690$606
70$878$791$680

To use it, divide the lump sum by $100,000 and multiply. A plan offering $200,000 or $1,500 a month to a 65-year-old man pays $750 per $100,000, against $761 that the lump sum buys at the Treasury rate: the lump sum is worth more.

Pension lump sum vs annuity calculator

On the SSA 2022 period life table, the same pricing as the annuity payout calculator: level monthly payments, nothing kept for an insurer’s costs. People in good health live longer than the population table assumes, which favours the annuity. A model comparison, not a recommendation.

Paid tool The right choice depends on the rest of your income: Social Security, savings and the tax each year. Personal PRO runs your whole plan year by year — a pension or the lump sum invested, what to withdraw, what to convert to Roth and the tax each year — with 10,000-path runs. Go PRO — $49 once → Compare what each plan includes →

Three ways to read an offer

Take the $200,000 or $1,500-a-month offer at 65 (man, single life):

Plans figure lump sums from interest rates and a mortality table the IRS publishes each month, so an offer moves with corporate bond yields (IRS segment rates; IRC §417(e)(3)). A pension that rises with inflation is worth more than these level-payment figures show.

The survivor option

A married participant’s pension is normally paid as a joint and survivor annuity, which keeps paying 50% to 100% to the widow or widower; taking a single-life pension or the lump sum needs the spouse’s written consent, witnessed by a notary or a plan representative (IRS: Qualified joint and survivor annuity). Covering two lives costs monthly income: at 65, a fair joint and 100% survivor pension pays 20% less than a man’s single-life one ($606 against $761 per $100,000). With a wife of 62, the $200,000 offer above would have to pay $1,171 a month as a joint pension to match the lump sum at the Treasury rate.

If a plan fails, the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation pays the pension up to a legal maximum that depends on the age payments start (PBGC); a lump sum moved to an IRA leaves the plan’s risk behind and takes on the market’s.

The tax: rollover vs cash-out (computed by the tax engine)

2026 federal tax on a $300,000 pension lump sum, standard deduction; a direct rollover to an IRA is not taxed until withdrawn.
Household and choiceFederal tax it adds
Single, 65, $24,000 of Social Security: rolled directly into an IRA$0
The same, taken in cash$74,557
The same, a pension of $1,800 a month instead: each year$176
Married filing jointly, 65 and 63, $36,000 of Social Security: taken in cash$56,416
Single, left the employer at 52, no other income: taken in cash$98,134
… of which the 10% additional tax$30,000
Single, left the employer in the year of turning 55: taken in cash$68,134

A cash-out is ordinary income in one year (IRS Topic 412), so it climbs the brackets and, here, makes $20,400 of the Social Security taxable too. 20% is withheld from the check, $60,000 on $300,000, even if you roll it over yourself within 60 days (Form W-4R); a direct rollover has nothing withheld. Before 59½ the 10% additional tax applies unless you left the employer in or after the year you turned 55 (IRS: Exceptions to tax on early distributions; IRC §72(t)). Spread over years, as a pension or as IRA withdrawals, the same money is taxed at lower rates.

An estimate from QuantCalc’s open tax engine (federal 2.6.4) for the 2026 tax year, federal only. Not tax advice: your return depends on facts this page does not ask about, so check a move with your tax preparer or custodian before acting. How the engine computes each line, with its official source: federal, state.

Common questions

Is it better to take a pension lump sum or the annuity?
Compare the monthly pension with what the lump sum buys: at 65, about $761 a month per $100,000 for a man and $690 for a woman at the November 3, 2026 Treasury yield. A pension paying more than that is the better deal for average health; the lump sum wins with poor health, a need for the money, or heirs to leave it to. The annuity also removes the risk of outliving the money, and a married couple’s joint and survivor form keeps paying the widow or widower.
How much is a $100,000 lump sum worth as a monthly pension?
At the 4.95% 10-year Treasury yield of November 3, 2026, on the SSA period life table with nothing kept for costs: $617 a month at 55, $678 a month at 60, $708 a month at 62, $761 a month at 65, $878 a month at 70 for a man; a joint and 100% survivor pension pays $606 at 65 (a man and a woman of the same age). Real insurer quotes are usually lower.
How is a pension lump sum taxed?
As ordinary income in the year you receive it, unless you roll it over (IRS Topic 412). Paid to you, 20% is withheld (Form W-4R), and before 59½ a 10% additional tax applies unless you left the employer in or after the year you turned 55 (IRS). Rolled directly into an IRA, nothing is taxed or withheld until you take it out. A single 65-year-old with $24,000 of Social Security who cashes out $300,000 owes $74,557 more federal tax that year.
What is the break-even age on a pension lump sum?
The age at which the payments received add up to the lump sum. On a $200,000 offer against $1,500 a month from 65, it is 76.2, and a 65-year-old man has a 74% chance of living to it on the SSA table. Break-even ignores interest; the implied rate the calculator gives does not.
Why did my pension lump sum offer go down?
Plans must figure a lump sum with no less than the present value at interest rates and a mortality table the IRS sets each month (IRC §417(e)(3); IRS segment rates). When those rates rise, the same pension is worth fewer dollars today, so the lump sum offered falls; when they fall, it rises.
Does my spouse have to agree to a lump sum?
In a defined benefit pension plan, yes. A married participant’s pension is paid as a qualified joint and survivor annuity, paying the survivor 50% to 100%, unless both spouses agree in writing to another form; the spouse’s consent must be witnessed by a notary or a plan representative (IRS; IRC §417).

Sources